Two files on the same metro map are not the same credit. Midtown still leases. The outer garden product is where we get slow.

We keep a simple book for Atlanta: infill inside the Perimeter, and everything else. Last quarter, small infill (8–40 units, Midtown, Old Fourth Ward, the BeltLine edge) leased in 30–45 days at asking or a small concession. Garden product in the southern and far-eastern suburbs sat 90-plus days with two months free.

That split is how two term sheets on the same week can be 75 basis points apart. We are not making a call on “Atlanta.” We are making a call on whether a specific block still has tenants who will pay without a tour bus of concessions.

What we will still finance

Value-add infill with a real renovation scope and in-place rents 15%+ below the renovated comps: yes, if the sponsor has finished that product in this metro. Ground-up in a submarket with three competing deliveries in the next 12 months: only with a thicker interest reserve and a lower LTC.

We originated one Midtown infill last quarter at 11.00% and 70% of cost. We declined two outer-ring garden files that were pitched as “the same Atlanta trade.” They were not. One of those sponsors later took a higher coupon from a national shop and still had to bring cash when the appraisal came in light.

If you have an Atlanta file, tell us the submarket in the first sentence, not the MSA. The desk already knows the MSA is large. The question is whether people are signing leases on that block this month.